Writing
AI for Small Churches: Start With the Work Nobody Has Time For
Where AI gives a small church staff real hours back, and the lines it should never cross.
November 15, 2026
If you work at a small church, you already know the math. There are more jobs than people. The pastor also runs the slides. The office manager is also the bookkeeper, the graphic designer and the person who answers the phone. Volunteers are generous, and tired.
When people talk about AI, small church leaders tend to hear either that it will change everything or that it is something to fear. I don't think either one helps you on a Tuesday morning.
I am a pastor, and I also help leaders and teams figure out where AI fits in their work. Here is the plain version of what I tell churches.
Start with the work nobody has time for
The best place to start is not the exciting stuff. It is the pile of tasks that never get done, or get done late, because nobody has the hours.
Think about the work that is necessary but draining:
- Turning a sermon into a short summary for the website or the email.
- Writing a first draft of the weekly announcements.
- Taking messy meeting notes and turning them into a clear list of who is doing what.
- Writing discussion questions for small groups from Sunday's passage.
- Translating a flyer for families in your church who speak another language, so a native speaker can review it instead of starting from scratch.
None of that is glamorous. All of it takes time away from people. That is exactly why it is a good place to start.
I live this myself. I run a daily kids podcast with no paid staff. Carpooling with Jesus, Goodnight Psalms and a few bonus shows go out on schedule because AI handles the first drafts of the work around each episode: show notes, captions, the email to families, the publishing checklist. I review and change every draft, I record every episode, and nothing goes out without my read.
Where human judgment has to stay
AI is good at first drafts. It is not good at being your pastor. Here is where I draw firm lines.
Pastoral care stays human. A grieving family, a marriage in trouble, a teenager who is not okay: those conversations belong to people. AI can help you remember to follow up. It should never be the one following up.
Private information stays private. Prayer requests, counseling notes, giving records and anything about a child should not be pasted into a tool unless you know exactly where that information goes and who can see it. If you are not sure, the answer is no.
Theology gets checked. AI will write something that sounds right and is not. Anything about Scripture gets read by someone who knows it, every time.
Your voice is yours. People in your church know you. If everything you send starts to sound polished and a little generic, they will notice. Use AI to get a draft on the page, then make it sound like you.
A person signs off. Nothing goes out to your church, your community or your volunteers without a human reading it first. That rule alone will prevent most of the problems people worry about.
Judge it by what it actually does
One habit has saved me a lot of trouble: judge AI by what it actually produces, not by what you hoped it would do. Run the task. Read the result. Did it save time, or did you spend just as long fixing it?
Some tasks will be a clear win. Some will not be worth it. Both answers are useful. You are not trying to use AI everywhere. You are trying to find the few places where it gives your people time back.
A simple way to begin
You don't need a big plan or a budget line to start. Try this:
- Make a list. Ask your staff and key volunteers, "What do you do every week that drains you and doesn't need you specifically?" Write it all down.
- Pick one task. Choose something low risk, like announcement drafts or meeting summaries. Nothing private, nothing pastoral.
- Try it for a month. Use it every week. Keep notes on what worked and what you had to fix.
- Write down your rules. A one-page list of what you will and won't use AI for is enough. Share it with your team so everyone is working from the same page.
- Decide together. At the end of the month, keep it, change it or drop it.
The point is people
The reason to do any of this is not efficiency for its own sake. It is so the people in your church office have more time for the work only they can do: praying with someone, training a new volunteer, sitting across the table from a family who needs help.
If AI can take an hour of formatting off your plate, that is an hour you can give back to people. That is a trade worth making.
Next step
Five minutes. Press play.
Speaking, interviews and AI help: heyjustinherman@gmail.com
